Man is the measure of all things!
Protagoras, the sophist, firmly believes that all value judgments are purely subjective. The significance of his philosophical beliefs is that what seems true to each individual is his only reality and the real world is different for each of us. Both Anaxagoras ( "„Things will be for you as you assume they are.„") as well as Empedocles and Parmenides are in total agreement with Protagoras' statement: "„"Man is the measure of all things, of those that are how they are and of those that are not how they are not."”.
The dramatic and harsh statement that generates currents and heated philosophical discussions. In the Platonic dialogue Theaetetus, Socrates asks Protagoras if he has read his own statement(?). „"I've read it many times. And doesn't it say something like: as each thing appears to me, so it is, according to me, and according to you, as it appears to you, for we are both human, you and I?"”
Of course, Aristotle has his own interpretation (in order not to be accused of mono-valent pleading, I also reproduce the text) in Metaphysics: „"Protagoras maintained that man is the measure of all things, which amounts to affirming that what each person seems to exist in reality. If this were so, it would follow that the same thing is and is not, that it is bad and good, and that all contradictory statements are equally true, because often the same thing seems beautiful to one person, while to another it is just the opposite. And what appears to each of us is the measure of things."”
I firmly believe that Aristotle is in a serious error and commits a violation of the principle of individual diversity and uniqueness, but, to repeat Protagoras' thesis, what seems true to Aristotle must necessarily be true for him. Not for me.
The moment we cancel Protagoras' statement, we open the way to tyranny and the imposition of a single vision. History records rivers of blood generated by these ideas and this intransigence..
