The Guardians of Terror. The New Prince.
Quis custodiet plaster custodes? – Who will guard the guards? / Juvenal's Satires
A question of acute topicality. Who will supervise the supervisors? Other supervisors? And these too? Since Plato, this question has been identified with the world of politics. Of corruption in the world of politics. Many solutions have been proposed and the only one that emerged was the necessity of the existence of high moral ideals. Transcendental. This is what civilized countries then applied in creating extremist nationalist, patriotic feelings within the community of "guardians": secret agents, police forces, army, politicians.
Unfortunately, power corrupts. Extremely few people have proven themselves immune to the incredible corrupting power of power.
A clear case is the Inquisition. Started as a movement to defend Christian beliefs, it soon became the most fearsome force of oppression of all. Of kings, nobles, peasants, merchants. Without supervision, it became despotic and it took bloody wars to be dethroned. Thousands of innocent people, however, lost their lives on the road to the "glory of the Inquisition".
These guardians have always started by being created as a force for social good. White cells of the social system. In the desire to protect them from the temptations of everyday life, they were strongly indoctrinated. And they were programmed in the spirit of "Fiat lux, pereat mundus" (let justice be done even if the world disappears). Stoicism taken to extremes gives birth to fanaticism.
The uncompassionate judgment of: "it is better for ten innocent people to go to prison than for one guilty person to escape.".
The power to destroy people and to dispose of "justice" at will, venal indoctrination, boundless and merciless hatred, the ability to subjugate all components of a state through fear (king, president, government, parliament, civil society, press, business world) has given birth and will give birth to monsters.
Nowadays we are face to face with a new Inquisition. Just read the newspapers. Listen to your friends. Look at how phones are hidden for fear of wiretapping. Read the fiery rhetoric of the inquisitors. "You are all guilty, I just don't have time to investigate you all." Three years ago a DNA prosecutor said this to me, sitting relaxed over a coffee where we had just met. He had already condemned me and hadn't even remembered my name.
I lived my first 18 years under Ceausescu's Securitate. I wasn't afraid like I am today. Back then we all had reason to be afraid (and as proof that I had illegally fled the country). Now I don't, but I am surrounded by everyone's fear (but I won't leave again). Fear is contagious. If you are innocent, you have nothing to be afraid of. God will save you. That's what the Inquisitors used to say before they locked you in a steel cage and submerged you for 10 minutes under water. If you drowned, you were guilty. Prosecutor's logic.
Our guards have become the first threat to everyone and, ultimately, to the existence of the state. Everyone is afraid of them. The credibility of the institutions of the Romanian state is destroyed (I was looking at how much hatred the official machines are viewed with) and a modern state is based on the credibility and support of the people in backing these institutions. The modern state exists through the social contract that legitimizes the power of the elected. Destroying the aura of the institutions, what are we left with?
With fear of gardeners.
Sad rulers who cannot fight the Praetorian Guard that changes emperors as it wishes, arrests and appoints its own people, and which already takes all state institutions as prisoners of the fear it has created.
The history of Rome can show you the danger. Rome was covered in blood by the abuses of the "guardians".
The history of the Inquisition is clearer. Its excesses are revealing.
The past few days have marked 20 years since the Mani Puliti action in Italy. What is happening now in Romania has already happened in Italy. The results are disastrous for the Italian state. Italy is still suffering after 20 years.
Read HISTORY because it repeats itself.
So, who will guard the guards?
I will return to this topic.
