Talmudic story

[…] We are taught like an oven made of tiles connected together
They are not subject to the rules of the pure and the impure. This is the opinion of Rabbi Eliezer, but the other sages thought
the contrary. Rabbi Eliezer rejected by all possible means
the arguments of the other rabbis, but they did not admit any of them.
„"If it is written that my decision will prevail, let this carob prove it."„", says Rabbi Eliezer. Immediately, the carob, plucked from the ground, moved a hundred cubits.
„"A carob tree proves nothing"”, said the other rabbis.
„"May this spring prove my righteousness"”, said Rabbi Eliezer. And immediately the water began to flow from the valley to the hill.
„"A stream of water proves nothing"”,said the other rabbis.
„"Then the walls of this house of learning will prove it!"„". The walls began to lean and were about to collapse when Rabbi Joshua shouted to them:
„"If the disciples of the Wise Men quarrel, what concern is it to you?"”
walls
they did not collapse, out of respect for Rabbi Joshua, but neither did they straighten up, out of respect for Rabbi Eliezer. And so they have remained to this day. Then Rabbi Eliezer said to the other Sages:
„"If it is written that my judgment will prevail, then the heavens will decide!"”. Immediately a voice came from heaven, saying:
„"What brings you to challenge Rabbi Eliezer? His judgment reigns supreme!"” At these words, Rabbi Joshua stood up and shouted:
„"She is not in heaven!"”  [Deuteronomy, chapter 30,12]
What
What did he mean by that? "That the Torah was given to us on Mount Sinai,
Rabbi Jeremiah explains, and we have no reason to heed a voice from
heaven!".
After this agitated meeting of the Talmudic Academy, Rabbi
Nathan met with the prophet Elijah and asked him what God was doing at the time this discussion was taking place. The answer was:
”"God smiled and said: my children defeated me and made me eternal..."”
What matters in this story is not the pure and the impure, but the status of truth. You can sympathize with Rabbi Eliezer, but he is mistaken when
is fighting for Truth. Democracy, for example, or the freedom of each
to choose, acceptance of certain rules and provisional validation of
votes….
„"God's most beautiful story"”. Jean Bottero-Assyriologist and Marc-Alain Quaknin-rabbi with Joseph Moingt-Jesuit
[ I was thinking about the implications of that Fiat lux pereat mundi from our perspective, Christians]

Similar Posts