The Popes' Quarrel

The papacy seems like a sacred institution today. Maybe it really is. In any case, history records a rather sympathetic episode related to the sacredness of the election of the Pope and the influences of politics in religious life.
Upon the death of Pope Gregory XI (1378), the people of Rome demanded the election of an Italian pope. And as vox populi, vox Dei, the cardinals elected the Archbishop of Bari, who became Pope Urban VI.
Urban VI was a bit of a weirdo, scheming and unbalanced, facts that attract the disapproval of the cardinals. Who, initially secretly, plot and elect another pope. An antipope. The Frenchman Robert of Geneva who becomes Pope Clement VII. Although it seems strange to elect another pope and the coexistence of two popes simultaneously, Pope Clement VII obtains recognition as pope by France, Portugal, Castile and Scotland. England and her allies (we are talking about the period of the 100 Years War) however remain with the Italian pope. Urban VI.
The situation seems strange and the papacy, chosen by God on Earth, seems to be losing credibility. So the cardinals meet and, to solve the problem of the two popes, they choose a third pope. How is it childhood? When two argue, the third wins? So the third pope simultaneously: Pope Alexander V. With the seat of the papacy in Pisa.

The charade ended when, exasperated by the ridiculous situation, the German Emperor Sigismund restored Catholic unity by appointing a fourth pope, Martin V, and annulling the first three papal elections. Down with Urban VI, Clement VII and Alexander V. Only Martin V.
So great was the emperor's desire to make Martin V pope that it no longer mattered that he, although noble, was not a priest. Details. He immediately makes him a priest. And pope. And that's about it.

PS: I'm not an atheist or a heretic. I'm just well informed.

Similar Posts