Biosecurity as a future dictatorial policy…

(reading: about 3 min.)
„"What is striking about the exceptional reactions and devices that have been implemented in our country (and not only in this one) is the impossibility of observing them beyond the immediate context in which they seem to operate. On the other hand, there are few who, as a serious political analysis would require, interpret them as symptoms and signs of a broader experiment, in which a new paradigm for governing people and things. In a volume published seven years ago, which deserves to be read carefully (Tempêtes microbiennes, Gallimard 2013), Patrick Zylberman described the process by which health security, which had previously remained outside political calculations, became an essential part of state and international political strategies.
What is at stake is nothing more than a kind of „health terror” as a tool to govern what was defined as the worst case scenario. In line with this worst-case logic, back in 2005, the World Health Organization had announced „two to 150 million deaths from the coming bird flu,” suggesting a political strategy that states were not yet ready to accept. Zylberman shows that the suggested provisions consist of three points:
1). building, based on a possible risk, a fictitious scenario in which data is presented in such a way as to favor behaviors that allow an extreme situation to be managed;
2) adopting a worst-case logic as a regime of political rationality;
3). the integral organization of the citizen corpus in such a way as to strengthen adherence to governing institutions to the maximum, producing a kind of superlative civicism in which the imposed obligations are presented as proof of altruism and the citizen no longer has a right to health (health safety), but becomes legally obligated to health (biosecurity).
What Zylberman described in 2013 has been verified precisely today. It is obvious that, beyond the state of necessity related to a certain virus that may give way to another in the future, what is at issue is the foreshadowing of a governance paradigm whose effectiveness far exceeds that of all forms of governance known to Western political history so far.
If already in the progressive decline of ideologies and political beliefs, security reasons allowed citizens to accept limitations on freedom that they were previously unwilling to accept, biosecurity proved capable of presenting the absolute cessation of all political activity and all social relations as a maximum form of civic participation. Thus, it was possible to witness the paradox that some left-wing organizations, traditionally accustomed to claiming rights and denouncing violations of the constitution, accepted without reservations limitations on freedoms, decided by ministerial decrees devoid of any legality and that not even fascism dreamed of imposing.
It is obvious – and even the governing authorities do not cease to remind us – that the so-called "social distancing" will become the model of the policy that awaits us and that (as) the representatives of a so-called task force, whose members find themselves in an obvious conflict of interest with the function they must exercise, have announced that this distancing will be taken advantage of to replace everywhere with digital technological devices human relationships in their physicality, which have become, suspect of contagion (political contagion, of course). University lessons, as already recommended by the MIUR, from next year will be held permanently online, people will no longer recognize each other by looking at each other's faces, which can be covered with a sanitary mask, but through digital devices that will recognize biological data collected on a mandatory basis and any "gathering", whether it is done for political reasons or simply out of friendship, will continue to be prohibited.
At issue is an entire conception of the destinies of human society in a perspective that, in many aspects, seems to have taken over from religions now in their decline, the apocalyptic idea of an end of the world. After politics has been replaced by economics, now, in order to govern, this too will have to be completed with the new paradigm of biosecurity, to which all other demands will have to be sacrificed. It is legitimate to ask whether such a society will still be able to define itself as human or whether the loss of sensitive relationships of the figure, of friendship, of love, will be able to be compensated, in fact, by an abstract and, presumably, entirely false sanitary security.”
May 11, 2020, Giorgio Agamben
Translation: Stefan Damian
Add a caption

Similar Posts