Libertarian totalitarianism
Interview with the Belgian publication L'Echo:
A faceless power exercises total control over people
You claim that George Orwell is a great political thinker. He described all the dictatorships of the 20th century and anticipated our era. What are the signs of totalitarianism in our day? Isn't that a bit of an exaggeration? Have we really entered a new form of dictatorship?
No, it is not an exaggeration, because I am not saying that we have returned to Nazism or Stalinism. What interests me is not how totalitarianism used to work, but how it works in the age of the internet, digitalization and mobile phones. This contemporary totalitarianism does not wear a helmet or boots. Instead, we live in a society of control: the fact that we can be listened to constantly, the fact that data is collected about us, etc. This society of control is at a crisis point that has never been reached before.
So, do new technologies bring us no advantage?
We are in a kind of voluntary servitude to new technologies. But sometimes the situation is very perverse. For example, to ensure confidentiality, you are asked to accept certain things… But, by accepting them, you give some information to GAFA (the initials of the four giants of the Internet Google – Amazon – Facebook – Apple nr). You can accept the control device, but you can also refuse it. But if you refuse it, you can no longer travel by plane, train, etc.
Did Orwell anticipate this?
Orwell expresses his thinking with the help of a novel. He uses fiction. But his SF is no longer fiction; it has become science. That telescreen that constantly watches over us exists today in reality. Orwell invented things related to the control and invisibility of powers. This is exactly what distinguishes the old totalitarianism from today's. Before, power had an identifiable face. But today, who decides? Where are the people who make these things possible? I am convinced that the guys on the American West Coast have a project of world domination and a transhumanist project.
Is runaway capitalism responsible for this situation?
Capitalism will not disappear; it is consubstantial with man. Today, there is no enemy in front of it. After the fall of the Soviet bloc, capitalism believed that it could triumph. Some, like Fukuyama, even said that it was the end of history, the total victory of liberalism. However, the world is not made up only of capitalists and communists. There are also spiritual powers, like Islam. We saw on September 11, 2001.
„"Populicides" and the death of representative democracy
Do you think representative democracy is dead?
Yes. There is no longer any connection between the people and their representatives. In assemblies and parliaments there is an over-representation of the liberal professions: lawyers, teachers, etc. Few are shepherds, taxi drivers or students. Which means that there is a part of society that is simply not represented. In addition, to hope to be elected, you must have money, conform to the requirements of an apparatus, pass through the sieve of a party. Representative democracy is a thing of the past. The referendum on the Maastricht Treaty („Maastricht Empire” is the subtitle of Onfray’s book „Theory of Dictatorship” – nr) was a perfect embodiment of its limit: the elected officials act against the people.
How do you define the populism that is so feared today, you who trust in the people for the rebirth of democracy?
I have no problem defining myself as a populist. However, I differentiate between populists and "populicides". This is where the problem lies; and not, as we are led to believe, between populists and democrats. Macron, Chirac and Mitterand are "populicides". These people do not want to govern for the people. The referendum for the citizens' initiative (This is the main demand of the Yellow Vests movement. It proposes the establishment of a kind of direct democracy, through which a certain number of citizens can call a referendum, without the need for the agreement of parliament or the president. The referendum would have the power to revoke a law approved by Parliament or a treaty, to amend the constitution or to revoke an elected official - no) is a very interesting idea. The idea of having revocable elected officials is a good thing.
Obviously, in the current context, the progressive cretinization of the people is a real problem. And here I will surprise you with what I said before: the great advantage of the Internet is that the people can go and look for alternative information. The fact that a legal text is conceived and criticized by the people is a splendid idea.
What do you think about the civil disobedience movements we see emerging?
When Thoreau spoke of civil disobedience, he was referring to the war against Mexico. When Martin Luther King appropriated this concept, he did it to fight against racism. So did Gandhi, when he wanted the independence of India. Today, everyone believes that civil disobedience must work permanently. The question that arises in connection with all these movements is the following: what is the great cause that must be defended? We are forced to note that it is often a personal cause. For example, a teacher will end up refusing to give a dictation to students or to organize an exam because he does not agree with a law of the Minister of Education... Refusing to give a dictation will not turn you into a Jean Moulin (one of the leaders of the French Resistance - no). I have an exceptional opinion about the Resistance. Civil disobedience must remain reserved for great common causes.
What would the climate emergency be like?
No, the great common cause would be the victory of the Yellow Vests. The climate emergency is a mask behind which commercial interests hide. For example, electric cars, which are presented to us as ecological, in reality they are not. They want to sell us a green capitalism, so-called "eco-responsible". Today, when they want to make us buy a product, they tell us that it is "organic". The true ecology, which I want, is confiscated by this urban ecology in the hands of advertising companies. Global warming is used, which cannot be denied, rejecting its true scientific causes.
Is Greta Thunberg, about whom you wrote a very polemical text, in your view an embodiment of this green capitalism?
This girl is in the hands of green capitalism, which uses ecology as a good sales pitch. At her age, no matter how intelligent she is, I can't imagine that she can have the necessary arguments that allow her to master the whole scientific stakes behind the ecological issue.
The peoples are fed up
How do you perceive the different social movements across the planet? Is there something that, above all differences, unites them?
Today, it is no longer possible to take the army to the streets, because everyone jumps on your head thanks – and in this case – to the circulation of information. However, I fear that all these movements are nothing more than a great democratic convulsion. One dictator leaves and another takes his place… And we believe that something has changed. Now, giving Macron the boot and putting Muriel Penicaud in his place (the current Minister of Labor, she was a member of the management of large corporations such as Dassault, Danone, Business France, Orange, etc.) does not mean a great democratic revolution.
All these movements are a sign that the people are fed up. They can no longer stand to see that there are some unspeakable fortunes and that there are some guys who make wars with the sole purpose of getting rich. Like Trump, who, with incredible cynicism, declares, after killing Baghdadi, that he did it to ensure the security of oil…
Today, thanks to social networks, people can take to the streets very quickly. This uprising of the peoples makes me happy and, at the same time, I fear that it will be seized by demagogues, who are always waiting for the right moment. The Yellow Vests were seized by Mélenchon (president of the left-wing anarchist group „France Unsubdued” – nr), by the violence of the destroyers and the „Black Blocs” (left-wing anarchists, their name comes from the black tracksuits they wear nr), etc.
In a way, it is a lesson of history: peoples have always suffered from these confiscations.
Don't hesitate to be intentionally polemical. Is this the role of the philosopher? Does the contemporary intellectual necessarily have to be a person engaged in the problems of society?
Yes, the word of intellectuals is needed in a society where everyone claims to be an intellectual. Nowadays, everyone gives us advice and tells us how the world should work. I don't understand why you should be surprised that I also give my opinion on many topics. Why would I be less legitimate than a football player?
You write: „The language is under attack.” What do you mean by that?
My father studied in the state education system. He knew how to write without mistakes. He made no logical errors. He had learned several great classics of literature. The destruction of school led to the destruction of intelligence. Now, the problem is less that the education system creates a thinking citizen and more that it produces a paying consumer. Less and less things are learned. Some tell us that there is no longer any need for dictations, grammar, etc. But the brain is a muscle: if you don't maintain it, it degenerates...
At the end of your paper, you state, „I’m not sure I want to be a progressive.” To what extent do you consider progressivism to embody a form of nihilism?
I oppose progressivism as it is presented to us today. Progress is not a good in itself. There can be a progress of evil, a progress of death. Telling a poor woman that her womb will be rented to make a baby is not, I think, progress. In that sense, I am not a progressive. I do not enter into the game of systematically pitting bad populists against nice progressives.
So can the libertarian socialist and anarchist that you are also be a conservative?
Of course. Retirement at 60 is a very good thing. It should be preserved. Where does this bizarre idea come from that if you live longer, you must necessarily work more? On the contrary, the burden of work should be reduced, and it is very good that workers retire earlier.
Making babies at home under the covers is something that has worked for centuries. Why would you want to change anything? You have to preserve what has worked.
Change at any cost makes no sense. If I'm shown proof that it's better, I can accept it, but if not...
Today, our civilization is groping forward like a blind man.