The place of every opinion..

There are points of view, generated by the social position of each one, by the degree of culture, by the existential aspirations of each one. different, sometimes even apparently antagonistic but, in essence, complementary. The need for "social" dialogue, a problem that has been stirring philosophy for over 2000 years.

”"Don't you like being politically equal with the multitude? But is it right to deny members of the same state the same rights? I am told that democracy is neither wise nor just [literally, equal] and also that the rich are the most fit to rule. But I will answer first that the demos means the whole state, and the oligarchy only a part, and secondly that the rich may be the best defenders of property, but the best advisers are the intelligent men, and the best listeners and judges of arguments are the many. And in a democracy all these are on an equal footing, whether they act separately or together.” 

The beautiful explanation used (according to Thucydides) in the speech of Athenagoras, the democratic leader of Syracuse.

As another clarification: what I like as an idea or discourse (for example the idea mentioned above) does not automatically represent what I believe. Democracy, the sublime utopia of humanity, doomed to constant failure. I can agree with the argument according to which oligarchy is the best defender of property. I am saddened that there is no (anymore) social category of "intelligent" (sophists, philosophers, people of culture and authentic thinkers) but I do not believe -at all- that "the many" are the best judges.

A beautiful utopia that has caused more social suffering than many exacerbated oligarchies. The absence of another/new social system will, however, maintain democracy as the only form of government until we find a more natural way. Unfortunately (again) it is the fact that, apparently, no one is actively looking for this path to new government. The reproach, however, is not brought to politicians but to modern philosophy and "intelligent people". The ivory tower as a condemnation of humanity. The only form of government that is trying to gain ground is religious dictatorship.

Sad humanity that has marginalized its thinkers, thus placing itself at the disposal of excesses.

Similar Posts