Logical float. Valla
Lorenzo Valla, a philosopher unjustly forgotten/cast into oblivion by the Catholic church, has an interesting logical exercise:
The existence of God versus human freedom.
– If God exists and knows everything, sees everything, foresees everything, what room is left for human freedom?
Because, if He knows in advance what people will want and then what they will do, how can we still talk about choice, freedom or free will? If there is no freedom of choice, people cannot be held responsible for what they are, say or do. Not being responsible, they cannot be guilty and therefore cannot be punished.
To deny freedom means to decree irresponsibility, but also to pave the way to the impossibility of punishment, both in this world and in the next.
But if we declare that He does not see, foresee, or know everything, we endanger His omnipotence and omnipotence.
It's easy to understand why Valla was consigned to oblivion. Almost. Not for current philosophers starting with Onfray.