Buridan's Donkey (republication)

It would be assumed that you know the fable of Buridan's Donkey (so at least read it now):

There was once a very hungry donkey who had a long way ahead of him.
equal to him, two haystacks identical in size and freshness.
Our donkey was very indecisive about what to eat and couldn't decide.
decision to start with or to choose. In the end
Our donkey starved to death, unable to make a decision. 

In other versions, the donkey is equidistant from the hay and the water.
being both hungry and thirsty. He dies of both hunger and thirst.
Versions, versions. I prefer the second one.

Jean Buridan/Johannes Buridanus) (ca. 1300 – 1358) was
a French philosopher whose writingslet's not find this fable.
Mainly because his name stuck to a fable in which philosophy
(moral determinism) is ridiculed. A kind of joke Radio
Yerevan. And so a minor philosopher enters immortality.

But here too I have a problem related to the antiquity of this fable, because Aristotle (On the Heavens - cosmological work) says:
„"...a man, as hungry as he is thirsty, and placed between
food and water, must remain motionless and die of hunger and thirst
thirst"”
mocking the Sophists' idea that the Earth
is stationary because it is circular and all forces must be
be equal in all directions.

The idea of this paradox between equal forces was, however, "discovered" by Abu
Hamid al-Ghazali (c. 1100 – The Incoherence of the Philosophers) where he says:
Let's assume that the man has two meetings ahead of him and he has one
strong desire to have both but cannot satisfy them
simultaneously. He will definitely go to one of them thanks to a quality
intrinsics that help him choose between two identical things
.
OK..maybe ours are "incoherent" but you are a little thief. And the argumentation "with certainty" + intrinsic quality, unjustified or logically explained is...literature not philosophy. Please....

However, this was immediately contradicted by the Moorish philosopher Averroes (1126-1198), who believed exactly the opposite. That is, like Buridan's donkey.

Buridan/al-Ghazali/Averroes? Hmm… the „greatness” of Arab philosophy in
The medieval period has a little secret: plagiarism. Some ..donkeys …

Continuing the discussion... Baruch Spinoza enters (big like):

[I]t may be objected, if man does not act from free will, what will
happen if the incentives to action are equally balanced, as in the case
of Buridan's ass? [In reply,] I am quite ready to admit, that a man
placed in the equilibrium described (namely, as perceiving nothing but
hunger and thirst, a certain food and a certain drink, each equally
distant from him) would die of hunger and thirst. If I asked, whether
such a one should not rather be considered an ass than a man; I answer,
that I do not know, neither do I know how a man should be considered,
who hangs himself, or how we should consider children, fools, madmen,
&c.

— Baruch Spinoza, Ethics, Book 2, Scholium, 1677

Similar Posts