reproval

Lorenzo Valla brought several reproaches against Stoicism (around 1447). The most important reproach (superbly summarized by Onfray)

[…] The worst thing that can be held against the followers of the Portico (the Stoics) is sadness, acedia which they generate by placing virtues so high that they remain unattainable. People are urged to behave like heroes: failing to do so, they languish in an irremediable melancholy. This inhuman ethics, even in the etymological sense, triggers human passions, very human, related to self-discontent. A guilty dissatisfaction. 

In support of Stoicism (yes, I sometimes need to support them), I would say that in our times we have an immense need for Stoics and even their exaggerations. Even that acedia in the face of the loss of moral, ethical and metaphysical cardinal points is necessary.

For a short and medium term recovery we need both Platonic idealism as well as stoicism. Hedonists will continue to exist, to enjoy and to dominate from the shadows of philosophical culture. After 2000 years of repression hedonism has learned to thrive in the shadows and wait.

Similar Posts