The law of retaliation.

While discussing the philosophy of law yesterday, we came to the law of retaliation.
What caught my eye is the fact that the Law of Retaliation represents Justice and, in no case, Law. As I mentioned, the legal system ("Law") has no intrinsic, causal connection with justice. I could say that Law is a sociological science that seeks to regulate interhuman relations so that cohabitation in large groups is possible. A justice focused on social regulations not on Justice or on Justice. Law emerged as a necessity to break the chains of revenge (I kill X, X's brother kills me, my brother kills X's brother, X's father... etc.). vs. I kill X, the Law punishes me, thus giving satisfaction to X's family and canceling personal revenge) and establishing rules of cohabitation. It did not start from the desire to do Justice. An immense confusion that persists so strongly in the consciousness of humanity.
The Law of Talion is, however, the exact opposite of legal Law, but it is the application of just Justice. An eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth. I said that Justice, in today's social model, is thought of and present only in Theology and Philosophy. It is also for this reason that the world has learned that Justice is only divine (something so often mentioned in popular discussions). Support for this idea is found in the Bible, both in the Book of Exodus ( ” „"And if there is any other injury, then he shall pay life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot, burn for burn, wound for wound, bruise for bruise"”) , in Leviticus (Lev. 24:19-21),(„He who kills a beast shall make restitution; and he who kills a man shall be put to death.„") and in Deuteronomy 19:16, 18, 19 and 21 ("„If an unrighteous witness rises up against a man to accuse him of wrongdoing… and if the witness is a false witness… you shall do to him as he would have done to his brother. And so you shall put an end to the evil… Your eye shall not spare him, but you shall require life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot. As a man does evil to his neighbor, so shall he be repaid.”).
However, it first appears in the Code of Hammurabi itself (1792-1749 BCE), where the law of retaliation had several forms: tooth for tooth, bruise for bruise, foot for foot, hand for hand, bone for bone, eye for eye.

Humanity has been stuck for almost 2000 years in the concept of Roman Law (extended throughout the civilized world and which is still the cornerstone of modern legal systems). It cannot be improved in its essence. It must change because it needs to be changed paradigm : the legal system should return to the achievement of Justice, Justice and leave the moderation of social and interhuman relations in the background. Today it would be possible because, after 2000 years of Law, human society has understood the need to apply these rules of cohabitation. I would almost leave the drafting of laws to sociologists because they could have a clearer idea of the needs of society and how these could be reflected in the legal system of Law.

The expressions (after various judgments) "Justice was not served" are baseless because the Judge did not a priori want to serve Justice but merely applied the rules of the Legal system to restore social ties.

To avoid confusion I would rename "right" to "„cohabitation„". The civil cohabitation system, the criminal cohabitation system, the fiscal cohabitation system.

Human society could not have emerged, thrived, or existed without the legal system. An indisputable fact. But that does not make it any less imperfect.

The main fault lies with philosophers: after all, who can create systems and propose new social models? After Plato's Republic and the Laws of Lycurgus, few ideas and few solutions. Philosophy's fault is that, having become arrogant and self-sufficient, it has isolated itself in an ivory tower where it seems to no longer provide solutions, systems and ideas for the practical application of ethics.

Similar Posts