History and racism

History and racism. – Marius Turda and Maria Sophia Quine
Polirom Publishing House 2019

Or "culture/anthropology for all".

Which is not bad. Culture (of any kind and in any
field) must be promoted as much as possible because its lack has already led to serious
slippages. One of these serious slippages is "political correctness".
A serious illness from which this book also suffers. The serious suffering that generates aberrations
(not this time) and logical fractures. To be honest, without these logical fractures
and "political correctness" a book discussing "race" and "racism" would be
was banned. And I don't think the authors have any ambitions to be martyrs of science.

But let's be clear: the book is worth reading and should be read. Especially because
this is the first time (probably) that you will have anthropological concerns/
racial. You can't even agree with me (or the authors) without reading it.
I met Mr. Marius Turda recently, at a conference
organized by the University of Bucharest. It made a strong impression on me and I
I was (still am) impressed by the vast culture and knowledge of national history.
interwar period (not only of anthropology). And of him as a man of culture and science.  
I later bought his last book that I managed to get my hands on.
I'm done. My main (major) dissatisfactions are related to:
a)     
Affirmation of the non-existence of races;
b)     
Mixing the concepts of "race", "ethnicity",
„"superiority", "nationality".
Taking them one by one.
1. Affirmation
the non-existence of human races.
This is the main conclusion of the book. It is not the first
time when I read materials by anthropologists through which they abolish (
directly and by logical deduction) the science whose researchers or teachers are
(Mr. Marius Turda is a professor at Oxford Brookes of the history of biomedicine). The statement
is politically correct but incorrect according to reality, optics, medicine,
common sense.
I look at an individual and identify it as belonging to the species
humans (most of them belonging to the subspecies Homo sapiens sapiens). Then he
identify as white, black, yellow, brown, red (North Americans), etc. Race
and skin color are Objective Biological Realities. I look and I see colors
different. If I looked deeper I would see clear structural differences
and classifiable. I'm not just talking about craniometry. But let's stick to something
clear: color. Precisely to prevent other potentially destructive classifications
(Aryans, Mediterraneans, Teutons, etc.) we must accept a classification
benign based on skin color. And if we don't call it "race" what would I call it
? Coloring ? That would be ugly. You look at the color of your skin and you know what you are.
Or, if you're in doubt, you're a mestizo. A cross between two or more races.
I don't see a problem here either. You're half-breed. You're not white, you're not black, you're not
yellow, you're half-breed. You're something. But you're not white. You're not black either. You still have to
to be something because you exist and you want to determine which race you belong to.
You can't convince me to look at a picture of a white person next to me.
of a black man and not see any difference. If you don't notice it, I can tell you
recommends an oculist (simple case) or a neurologist (long side and
dangerous). Don't ask me to "abstract" from it. So races exist.
From here, however, to asserting the superiority of one over the other
another… long road. Let's not go down that road for now. Let's clarify this obvious thing.
Day is day, night is night, white is white, yellow is yellow, and black is
black. Ok? Let's move on.
2. Mixing
the concepts of "race", "ethnicity", "superiority", "nationality".
His Excellency, over the course of over 140 pages, states that
these concepts of race, ethnicity, nationality, civilization or culture were
confused and "tricked" into demonstrating certain preconceived ideas or
valid but unsubstantiated. Obviously affirming a superiority of a nation or
races. Which is debatable and, in most cases, erroneous. I am in
I completely agree with your opinion. What I don't understand is how to use
exactly the same confusions in demonstrating the opposite: the non-existence of "human races".
Exactly the same methods used in both directions. In demonstrating "superiority"„
and "non-existence".
At the same time, we cannot disregard some positions or ideas of some thinkers,
anthropologists, politicians only based on the subsequent effects of doctrines
A false causal relationship should not be forced where none exists. And
even if there is a causal relationship we cannot ignore
the hypotheses, arguments, evidence and thinking of those with whom we are not
agreement, even if the effects are known.  We all agree that his Nazism
Hitler was both wrong and created pseudoscience. However, we cannot
eliminates en bloc, without a cold analysis, all the hypotheses of that period and
the philosophical studies or ideas of interwar and Nazi Germany. The same
manipulation (sometimes subtle) in the dismantling of the vast majority of "enthusiasts"„
racism. And by suddenly canceling them, we cancel the very discussion over time related to
about the existence of human races. Totally wrong.
What made me happy, however, is that I would like to suspect
our distinguished compatriot of pleasant cunning: citing the sources used,
the names of the authors, the titles of the works of the international pro-"racist" schools
(especially European ones). These little quotes (of course contested by the author) will give you
They arouse attention because you didn't know them. And you write them down and then analyze them directly.
and without external interference so that you can form your own opinion. A
long list of thinkers on racism, the existence of races, philosophers,
doctors, anthropologists, ethnographers, politicians or leaders. If the truth
emerges from the confrontation of ideas, then, of course, we must give them the floor.
So… read, take notes, search in second-hand shops or in scanned old books (a few
posted by me myself). Let us think for ourselves and decide what we believe.
The existence or non-existence of human races seems to me a question
without purpose. You cannot ignore physical reality. Biological races exist and it is important to us
easy to notice. They are not identical and have notable differences. And they must
listed and classified.  Mestizos
exists. And it accelerates. However, the theory of physical superiority, of the potential
cultural, creative or intellectual of a particular race. I say questionable and not necessarily
inaccurate. Of course, here we enter the realm of subjectivity and "political" incorrectness.
But an area that must, at some point, be researched and clarified. Science hates "areas"
"white areas", areas prohibited from research.  
But if we want to have the right to have an opinion, we must first
to formulate it, let's delve into the study of racism and anthropology. And the book "History and Racism" by our compatriot "lost" in London is
the best point in this search.

Similar Posts